FRACTURES OF THE PATELLA

¹ The Wingfield-Morris Orthopaedic Hospital, Royal Air Force Orthopaedic Service, Oxford, England

1. A series of 196 fractures of the patella has been reviewed.

2. The treatment adopted was excision of the whole bone—l0l; excision of part of the bone—33; open reduction and suture—18; suture with later excision—14; no operation—30.

3. The average time of post-operative disability varied from 3·6 to 5·3 months. The time was appreciably less when operation was carried out before the fourteenth day than when it was done later.

4. An attempt was made to follow up, two to five years after injury, those patients in whom the result was not influenced by other major injuries of the limbs or by unexpected complications. Replies to questionnaires were received from 116 patients.

5. Of these, all regained a good range of movement, varying from 90 degrees of flexion to full movement, whether treatment was by excision of part or all the bone, or by open reduction and suture.

6. The late results of excision of the patella, as estimated by the patients themselves two to five years after treatment, showed that there was considerable residual disability.

7. After total excision of the bone only 5 per cent. of patients considered that the knee was normal; 90 per cent. complained of aching; 60 per cent. complained of "giving way." After excision of one fragment, about half the patients regarded the knee as normal and half complained of aching and stiffness.

8. The number of fractures in this series treated by accurate internal fixation was too small to make justifiable comparisons.

9. The indications for non-operative treatment, open reduction and accurate internal fixation, excision of one fragment, and excision of the whole bone are discussed.

10. Excision of part or all the patella is often inevitable, but some claims made in the past for the results of this operation are not substantiated.