The advantages of titanium alloy over stainless steel plates for the internal fixation of fractures. An experimental study in dogs

An experimental study is reported of fracture healing in the femora of 36 Beagle dogs, comparing the results of using stainless steel plates with those of using less rigid titanium alloy plates. The alloy plates led to the appearance of a small amount of periosteal callus without any histological evidence of fracture instability, thus allowing the radiological assessment of fracture union. This also produced less bone loss during the remodelling phase. Radiological measurements 24 weeks after osteotomy showed cortical thickness to be reduced by six per cent under titanium alloy and by 19 per cent under stainless steel, while histological measurements showed a total bone loss of 3.7 per cent under titanium alloy and of 11 per cent under stainless steel plates. Removal of the titanium alloy plates after eight weeks followed by a recovery period of 16 weeks produced an increase of cortical thickness of 69 per cent and a gain in total bone mass of 30 per cent. Titanium alloy plates also produced less soft-tissue reaction than stainless steel plates. It is concluded that this alloy is a promising material for internal fixation devices.