Sir,
We read this paper with interest and would like to make the following comments.
The progression and recurrence of some bone cysts could be related to
continued high pressure within the cyst. This might explain the benefit
of leaving Kirschner1 wires implanted into the cyst and, perhaps,
injecting the cyst with cortico-steroid.
The following seems to support this thesis:
A 38-year-old opera singer presented with a fracture of the surgical
neck of the humerus, associated with an extensive ’simple’ bone cyst. For
some years she had been having an 'aching discomfort' in the arm. The
fracture was treated by forearm support for six weeks, and consolidated. A
protecting support was supplied in anticipation of the cyst healing.
However, the cyst remained, slowly increasing in size. Bone grafting
was considered, but the patient wished to avoid a scar which would detract
from her stage appearance, and she was unable to set aside time for a
protracted convalescence.
At four years post-injury, needling the cyst revealed a pressure
of about 90 mm of clear fluid within. A Spitz-Holtzer
ventricular drain was inserted into the cyst, draining into the peritoneal
cavity and was removed after 22 months.
Follow-up radiology over the year after insertion of the drain showed
reduction in the size of the cyst, thickening of the cortex, reduction of
scalloping and deposition of visible bone within the cyst and around the
drain. The support was abandoned.
Because the 'aching' pain experienced prior to the breakage had not
recurred the patient declined further radiology.
The limb has withstood the rigours of bringing up children as a
single mother, and all the stresses and strains of daily life with full upper limb
function, over a 23-year post-surgical follow-up.
J.P. Driver-Jowitt,
Orthopaedic Surgeon,
Private Practice,
Cape Town, South Africa.
1. Chigira M, Shimizu T, Arita S, Watanabe H, Heshiki A. Radiological evidence of healing of a simple bone cyst after hole
drilling. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 1986;105:150-3.